Do immigrants increase the crime rate? It’s a widely held view in the politically charged debate over illegal immigration and sanctuary cities. But a UC Irvine criminologist says it’s an assumption unsupported by the facts. And a longtime Anaheim cop suggests immigrant crime is a non-issue in local law enforcement. UC Irvine criminologist Charis Kubrin said on the "Inside OC with Rick Reiff" public affairs program that hundreds of studies over the past 15 years have all reached the same conclusion: "Immigrants are less crime-prone than the native population" and "immigration to an area causes crime to go down rather than up." Retired Anaheim police Capt. Joe Vargas, who joined Kubrin in a discussion about the rising crime rate, said that in years of attending international chief of police conferences the problem of immigration "was never discussed."
"We talked about gangs, we talked about drug trafficking, we even talked about dysfunctional family homes being a major cause of crime. Never was it immigrants," Vargas said.
Kubrin lamented that her and colleagues’ findings "have not made their way into the public imagination. … You will hear people say left, right and center that immigrants are crime-prone, they are causing our crime rates to go up, right? The (presidential) executive orders we are seeing now reflect that assumption, and it is not true."
Vargas said crackdowns on illegal immigration make it tougher for local law enforcement to keep communities safe:
"The challenge for the police executives in our cities is the fact that they have large immigrant communities and they have to connect with those communities … It creates a huge problem when, let’s say, ICE (U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement) shows up and is rounding up people and asks for local assistance, and with the social media today … the next thing you’ve got the entire neighborhood surrounding them, and now what do the local police do when they say, 'Well, we’re not working with Immigration,' but now we have to protect them and help them? It puts us into a bit of a tough spot.
"Plus, many people like myself … how many of our Hispanic officers are direct descendants from illegal immigrants? And now … people are saying, ‘We want you to go out and pick up people that look like your mom and dad and your aunts and uncles."
Kubrin and Vargas also agreed that while gang violence remains a big concern, it is not as much a scourge as in the recent past.
"The 1990s were ridiculous," Vargas said. "I was a patrol officer and a supervisor during that era and it was routine to get four or five shootings in a single weekend. We’re light years away from that. But that doesn’t mean squat to the person who’s a victim of a gang-related crime."
Kubrin and Vargas differed on the best way to reduce citizen-cop confrontations.
"What I think these cases raise is the question of what can be done in police departments and in police community relations, community is part of that, in order to minimize these incidents happening?" Kubrin said.
"What happened to compliance?" Vargas asked. "The number one way to reduce police use of force across the country is compliance."
The discussion, second of two parts, is airing this week on PBS SoCal and Cox. Show times are here www.rickreiff.com. The show can also be viewed on You Tube.
Part one of the discussion is also on YouTube, as is the show's Open Mic segment.
Opinions expressed in editorials belong to the authors and not Voice of OC.
Updated May 10, 2017
Previous Columns, Stories:
May 10, 2017 - Immigrants Crime-Prone? Cop, Criminologist Say It Ain’t So
May 10, 2017 - Ila Borders’ Baseball (and Life) Odyssey
May 2, 2017 - ARE POLICE BACKING OFF?
Apr. 14, 2017 - State Treasurer Struggles to 'Bank' Pot, Casts Doubt on Bullet Train
Mar. 26, 2017 - Reiff: OCC Controversy Debate: Faculty Rights, Conservative Push Back
Jan. 19, 2017 - Reiff: Lockyer Suggests Fellow Dems Cool Anti-Trump Rhetoric
Jan. 9, 2017 - Reiff: Krom Defends Great Park Legacy, Raps Project's "Commercialization"
Dec. 14, 2016 - Reiff: Trump Operative Warns California on 'Collision Course'
Oct. 3, 2016 - Inside OC: Newsom Touts Jobs, Ammo Restrictions, Softens Stance on Bullet Train
Sep. 27, 2016 - Inside OC: Experts Skeptical of Sanchez' 'GOP Southern Strategy'
Aug. 17, 2016 - Inside OC: Mike Harrah – Two Major Santa Ana Projects on Way
Aug. 8, 2016 - Inside OC: Chapman University Incoming President Daniele Struppa Talks Expansion
July 29, 2016 - Inside OC: A Libertarian Long Shot to The Presidency
June 20, 2016 - Doti Just Missed This List
May 13, 2016 - Sheriff Hutchens Says Likely to Run Again; Discusses Jail Break, Informant Scandal
Apr. 11, 2016 - Inside OC: Former OC Register Owner Eric Spitz Talks About Mistakes, Future
Feb. 26, 2016 - Irvine's Jeff Lalloway Says Great Park Lawsuits Unlikely
Feb. 1, 2016 - Inside OC: Anaheim's Mayor Tom Tait Sounds Off
May 19, 2014 - Allergan Assessment: Déjà Vu & Differences
Jan. 30, 2012 - Make Way for CSU Long Beach; Farewell Column
Jan. 23, 2012 - Peter Churm, OC Pioneer; Lincoln Club's 50th; CFO Humor
Jan. 16, 2012 - Can State Rebound? McCluney's Brush With Steve Jobs
Jan. 9, 2012 - Albert Pujols' Econ Stimulus; Bill Gross Likes Ron Paul
Jan. 2, 2012 - Ritz' Brave New Year; Charitable Guy's Painful 2011
Dec. 19, 2011 - Holiday Spirit: Augie's Quest, Tommy's Gifts; Koll's Last Parties
Dec. 12, 2011 - OC Money, Politics: Challenge to Unions; Billionaire Donors
Dec. 5, 2011 - Another BCS Win For OC; Kay Warren, D.C. VIP
Nov. 28, 2011 - Diocese's Cathedral Win Called 'Miracle;' Forgotten Kingmaker
Nov. 21, 2011 - Not-So-Fat Lady Will Sing; New Bren Baby
Nov. 14, 2011 - Chinese Influx to OC? The New 'Two Californias'
Nov. 7, 2011 - PC Wiz Targets Conference Room; Nixon Chapter Ends
Oct. 31, 2011 - A 'Princess' Passes; Prez Hopeful Cain Missing in OC
Oct. 24, 2011 - Hoag Biotech Deal; Ritz Must Move; Irvine Co. Departure
Oct. 17, 2011 - Healthcare Reform Gets Bad Prognosis; Guv Says 'Thanks'
Oct. 10, 2011 - This OC Treasurer Avoids Headlines; Chris Cox Coverboy
Oct. 3, 2011 - Mudgett's New Gig: Workouts; OC Hosts Women VIPs
Sep. 26, 2011 - New UCI Dean Wants to Partner; John Wayne Auction
Sep. 19, 2011 - Some Tension but No Arrests at This Israeli's Talk
Sep. 12, 2011 - Chapman Seeks Biz Dean; Pyott, Herbert Close Friends-Now
Sep. 5, 2011 - Great Park Approval Shakes Irvine Politics; Perry, Then Christie
Aug. 29, 2011 - Lyon Cars Fetch $12.5M; Mike Ellzey, Great Park Survivor
Aug. 22, 2011 - Tale of Two Police Departments; Iraq Mea Culpas
Aug. 15, 2011 - OC Ballplayers on Screen with Pitt; State Ranked 'Worst'
Aug. 8, 2011 - Oklahoma Billionaire In Cathedral Drama; BK Bragging Rights
Aug. 1, 2011 - Vegas Bullet Train Gets Key OK; Allergan Exec Moves
July 25, 2011 - Latvian Leader Gets 'Botox Treatment; Harrah Ready, Again
July 18, 2011 - OCers Join Royal Welcome; DiCaprio Heads Fisker List
July 11, 2011 - Schuller Gets Snub From His Board, Visit from Chapman
July 4, 2011 - Corporate Counsels Loosen Their Ties; Editor Wears Hat
June 27, 2011 - Bren Hosts Guests Richer Than Him; Fairgrounds Fissure
June 20, 2011 - United Way Gets Irvine Co. Boss; Welsh Sees Whales
June 13, 2011 - Darwin in Neverland: Fashionista on MJ; Pageant's New Voice
June 6, 2011 - Hyundai Sales Rising With Gas Prices; UCI-China Linkup
May 30, 2011 - Hollywood South: Jannard's Hot Camera, MacGillivray's 'One Ocean' Campaign
May 23, 2011 - Chapman Plans China Campus; Agran's History of Irvine 'Anniversary' Angels Lead 'Bad News' Dodgers; Family Chef
May 16, 2011 - 'Anniversary' Angels Lead 'Bad News' Dodgers; Family Chef
May 9, 2011 - OC 50 Grows More Global in Flavor; Bren Imposter Deal
May 2, 2011 - Wang's Waning Waist; Robin's Divorce Lawyer; Todd's Biz Backers
Apr. 25, 2011 - Nixon Group Shuns Woodward, Bradlee; Taking on Defense
Apr. 18, 2011 - UCI Sees Giving Rebound; Around the World in 15 Days
Apr. 11, 2011 - Branson, Stearnses Jet-Hop in SoCal; $5M UCI Gift
Apr. 4, 2011 - Calling Rich Bruins: UCLA Keepsake On Auction Block
Mar. 28, 2011 - Koontz Has Real Scare; Congress VIPs Visit OC
Mar. 21, 2011 - OC's World Ties: Fest Aids Japan, Turbi Blasts Gadhafi
Mar. 14, 2011 - Check Out These Political Bedfellows; $300M 'Handshake'
Mar. 7, 2011 - Chapman's New Dean: Credentials, Quips, Less Controversy
Feb. 28, 2011 - Great Park Fights Brown's Tax Plan; Old O's in OC
Feb. 14, 2011 - UCI Prof Teaches Live from Cairo; SCR's Next Act
Feb. 7, 2011 - Argyros Cables in Wikileaks Disclosures; Koontz for Moorlach
Jan. 31, 2011 - Contrite Spitzer Urges Supes to Fight On; Mayor's Near Gaffe
Jan. 24, 2011 - OC Execs Form Bears Rooting Section; Reagan Statue Drive
Jan. 17, 2011 - Segerstroms Get More Name ID, Center Gets Naming Rights
Jan. 10, 2011 - Bill Gates Starts Year in OC; Laguna's Lament
Jan. 3, 2011 - Keeping Opera Alive in OC; 2011 Predictions
Dec. 27, 2010 - Life After ICN: Milan Does China, Russia, Sacramento
Dec. 13, 2010 - UCI on Hiring Spree; Tiger Talks Up His Foundation
Dec. 6, 2010 - Nick Gets Jim's Yacht Impounded; Tait Aims at Regs
Nov. 29, 2010 - McMonigle Gets Record, Comerica Loan Dispute; L.A.-to-Irvine Exodus?
Nov. 22, 2010 - Another Merage Makes His Mark; Broadcom By the Numbers
Nov. 15, 2010 - Dianne, Loretta to Hoag's Rescue; Jerry Lewis Out-Hammed
Nov. 8, 2010 - Broadcom Taps Pundit As Political Point Man; Election Notes
Nov. 1, 2010 - Royce May Get Key Post; Ko Back, as Artist
Oct. 25, 2010 - Bid May Bring Free-for-All; Fall in New York
Oct. 18, 2010 - Not Everyone on Board Pringle Train; Chile Sees Oakley
Oct. 11, 2010 - Del Mar Learns From Costa Mesa; Cash for Dems
Oct. 4, 2010 - Big Audition: 70 Vie to Succeed SCR's Founders
Sep. 27, 2010 - Big Audition: 70 Vie to Succeed SCR's Founders
Sep. 20, 2010 - From Afghan Warlords to Deputies Union; Remembering Rodnick
Sep. 13, 2010 - OCer's Big Gift To MIT; Ready, Cameras, Triplets!
Sep. 6, 2010 - Big Winners in Bren Case: Lawyers; Barney Does OC
Aug. 30, 2010 - Call Her 'Hey You' Fiorina; Pros At Pelican Hill?
Aug. 23, 2010 - Headlands Buyers Few, But Famous; Businesses Fearing 'Double Dip'
Aug. 16, 2010 - RE Slump's Silver Lining: Lower Taxes; Governor Moorlach?
Aug. 9, 2010 - It's Official: Wirta Running Bren's Key Group; Tiger Talks
Aug. 2, 2010 - Callahan Called by Grieving Widow; Receiver for State?
July 26, 2010 - New Trojan AD Haden Will Keep Ties to RLH
July 19, 2010 - Irvine Co. Watch: Ray Wirta Gets Ninth Floor Office
July 12, 2010 - Argyros Reflects on a Homerun-Griffey; Granddad Lemmon
July 5, 2010 - Inside OC Fair Deal: Cash Flow, Ringers, Lawmakers
June 28, 2010 - Amazing Augie Taps Out Another Book; John Tu, Drummer
June 21, 2010 - Bad Call? Concerned Trojan Alum Wants Congressional Review
June 14, 2010 - Does Toyota Face Tidal Wave or Puddle? Election Pain
June 7, 2010 - How Broadcom Hires; MacGillivray's Bash Draws Royalty, Stars
May. 31, 2010 - Adios Petri Dish? High-Tech Test for Ocean Water
May. 24, 2010 - Robinson, Aitken Make Judge Selna's Cut; Lawler Goes Fishing
May. 17, 2010 - Will Carona Beat Rap? Chick-fil-A Screens Like CIA
May. 10, 2010 - No Last Laugh From Fortunate Heir Tim Hoiles
May. 3, 2010 - Chancellor Does 80 In Hydro Car; Wise Men Write
Apr. 26, 2010 - UCI, Chapman Ace Report Cards; Want a Boat Slip?
Apr. 19, 2010 - Goodness! Con Turned Pastor Hires Religion Writer Turned Atheist
Apr. 12, 2010 - Loretta's Leverage; Mark Sanchez Nears Endorsement Deals
Apr. 5, 2010 - 'Arabia' New Kind of Imax Adventure; Disney-OCTA Deal
Mar. 29, 2010 - Back to Business For Henry, Broadcom; Fairgrounds Update
Mar. 22, 2010 - Breast Cancer Survivor Gets 'Supreme' Treatment; Busy GOP Schedule
Mar. 15, 2010 - Swallows, Investors Return to South OC; Busy Wedding Season
Mar. 8, 2010 - State, County Discuss Fairgrounds 'Plan B'; Playboy Avoids Tiger
Mar. 1, 2010 - On Deck: Redoing Angel Stadium, Again; Top Toshiba Field
Feb. 22, 2010 - Musco's Relief Pod Helps in Haiti; Samueli Takes Train
Feb. 15, 2010 - Agran, Teller Have 'Social' Lunch; From Pimco to Citigroup
Feb. 8, 2010 - Slow Economy Not Stopping These Guys; Gus Owen Returns
Feb. 1, 2010 - No-Spin Zone At Irvine Co.; Raj Does Dome
Jan. 25, 2010 - Fair Play: Manley Sees Another Gem; Nancy '29' Wilhelm
Jan. 18, 2010 - Pre-Pre-Med Course at JSerra; UCLA's Legal Win
Jan. 11, 2010 - The Other BCS Winner: Newport; Krafcik Kudo
Jan. 4, 2010 - UCI Law School No Longer Free, But Still a Deal
Dec. 28, 2009 - Hoag: VIPs' Last Stop; Nicholas Deal? New Year Predictions
Dec. 14, 2009 - Exactly What Did Henry Say? Museum's General and Troops
Dec. 7, 2009 - Patient Bean Counting: Diedrich's Big Winner; Grippo's New Guy
Nov. 30, 2009 - D.C. in OC as Pols Come Calling; Curious Case of Pang, Irvines
Nov. 23, 2009 - Inflation or Deflation? Take Your Pick; Detente in Anaheim
Nov. 16, 2009 - Fairgrounds Deal Loses Ground; Professor Has Cautions for California
Nov. 9, 2009 - Recession Hits Golf Club Members, Too; Carly's Biz Backers
Nov. 2, 2009 - Buffett, Gross Top Bloomberg Survey; Playoffs Sans Pringle
Oct. 26, 2009 - Mayors Trash Talk On Angels-Yankees; Carly's Big Date
Oct. 19, 2009 - Pringle's Tax Panel Faces Long Odds; Meg Skips Debate
Oct. 12, 2009 - Gates, Other Buffett Pals Party (Quietly); Baugh and Brown
Oct. 5, 2009 - British Consul Tries U.S. Healthcare; Execs See Slow Recovery
Sep. 28, 2009 - Windfall Brings Fisker Opportunity, Critics; Guv Pitches OCPAC Fest
Sep. 21, 2009 - How UC Lessened Investment Losses; Ueberroth Eyes Deals
Sep. 14, 2009 - Who Needs Wall Street? Not Merage Grads; Web Winner
Sep. 7, 2009 - Singleton Still Likes Freedom, But No Wooing for Now
Aug. 31, 2009 - Hyundai Cashes in On Clunkers; OCers Cruise the Concours
Aug. 24, 2009 - They're Back: Met-Rx Redux, Sugar Ray Plays
Aug. 17, 2009 - UCI Cost Cutter; Ex-Californians Rip Golden State
Aug. 10, 2009 - Law Firms Add SEC Talent; Biz Profs Pan Clunker Program
Aug. 3, 2009 - Another Shakeup in Nick's Defense Team; Campbell Does CNBC
July 27, 2009 - Zimbabwe Postcard from Paul Freeman; locals at Cooperstown
July 20, 2009 - 'Last Great Estate' for Low-Key Developer; OC's Fed Crime Rise
July 13, 2009 - Arte's New Home; Ackerman Flips, Says Time for Convention
July 6, 2009 - Texas Guv Woos SoCal Auto Club; Muzzy's New Gig
June 29, 2009 - He Slayed Enron's Ken Lay, Now Defends Countrywide's Mozilo
June 22, 2009 - Local Effort to Buy Fairgrounds; New Bren Adviser
June 15, 2009 - Ex-Socialite Ready For Biz Spotlight; Forbes Finds Fisker
June 8, 2009 - Congrats and Mansion Requests for Flanders; Nick's Night Out
June 1, 2009 - OC's Fiscal Image: Chump to Champ; Temporary Turquoise
May 25, 2009 - Legal Headlines: Robinson v. Tobacco, Callahan v. Blackwater
May 18, 2009 - Will Flanders Hit The Bunny Trail? Rados Remembered
May 11, 2009 - Recession? Big Gifts For Chapman, UCI; Another Strand Sale
May 4, 2009 - Business-Friendly? OC Biz Leaders Support Prop 1A
Apr 27, 2009 - Yale, Move Over: UCI Law's Bold Tuition Gambit
Apr 20, 2009 - Mini-Madoff? Pang Battles Allegations; Gaddi's New Gig
Apr 13, 2009 - Beard's Off, Now He Seeks Tax Cut; Recalling O'Neill
Apr 6, 2009 - Samueli Not on Thin Ice with NHL; Magic in OC
Mar 30, 2009 - Nick Unplugged: New Image Stresses Business Deals, Charitable Work
Mar 23, 2009 - Obama Draws Some Consultants; OCBJ Draws Entrepreneurs
Mar 16, 2009 - Don Koll Gets Surprise Visitor; Igor Holds Court
Mar 9, 2009 - Prolific Prof Pumps UCI Law Ranking; McKnight Surfs On
Mar 2, 2009 - GOP Splits Over Anaheim Train, State Budget Deal
Feb 23, 2009 - Chapman's Prop. 8 Divide; A-Rod Taps OC Crisis Manager
Feb 16, 2009 - Meg Taps OC; St. John Goes Back to Black
Feb 9, 2009 - OC's Baseball Owner; Sanchez Against Bailout Before She's For It
Feb 2, 2009 - Game Over: Arte Swallows Legal Fees; Dana Helps Debbie
Jan 26, 2009 - Carona's Celebration; Mark Sanchez's Agent; Wylie Snaps Dustin
Jan 19, 2009 - Glenn Told You So; The General's Back; Farewell, Tim
Jan 12, 2009 - OC Readies Obama Wish Lists; More Intrigue in Irvine
Jan 5, 2009 - Attention, Landlords: Sheriff Seeks Space; Cheap Obama Party
more OC Insider Columns 2006-2008 ...